The Impact of “Full Ride” Medical School
Want a good smack in the face with some good old-fashioned common sense? Check this out. What you will see is an article that reviews the impact of NYU’s Grossman Medical School giving, starting in 2018, all current and future medical students free tuition. A generous move for sure, and one likely to attract medical students who otherwise might have gone to the Harvard’s and Georgetown’s of the world. But how about the expressed purpose of the move, i.e., to attract more students who will feed into primary care, and to attract a more ethnically and socially diverse student body?
Read the piece and think about it. A free ride looks just as good to me if I am going into one of the lucrative specialties, like dermatology or radiology, as it does if I am headed for primary care. Free tuition did nothing to shape the direction of NYU graduates’ specialty choice. Zero. Nada.
Similarly, as long as metrics like GPA and MCAT scores are the primary selection criteria used nationwide, and minority applicant pools remain stagnant, free tuition does little to increase the diversity of the medical profession overall. Sure, more minority students may be drawn to the free tuition at NYU, but only at the expense of other schools.
Bottom Line. Much talk is heard about “unintended consequences.” Civilians killed in air raids on military installations, etc. But how about “intended consequences?” Shouldn’t somebody be looking at a generous but expensive program like free medical school at NYU and ask the question, “How is that going to make happen what we want it to make happen?”