It Is Wrong For Doctors To Retire “Early?”

The gentleman pictured above is Dr. Jimmy Turner, the self-proclaimed “Physician Philosopher”. In this post, he sets out to debunk the title shown above. In doing so, he argues that a physician’s early retirement does not render the slot he occupied in medical school a waste. How many years should a doctor be required to practice in order to make his education worthwhile? 10? 20? Until he dies? Good question!

He also defuses the concept of early retirement contributing to the physician shortage. Here, he argues that too few doctors entering the field, rather than too many doctors leaving medicine, is the actual cause of the doctor shortage. He’s probably right again!

Of course, Dr. Turner has an axe to grind here. He coaches physicians on the principles of FIRE, Financial Independence and Retiring Early. 

As I pondered this piece, I thought of the work I do as a Board member at Volunteers In Medicine on Hilton Head Island, SC. We have 10,000 patients who would otherwise be medically underserved. And what lets us care for all of these patients with only a minimal budget? Volunteers. RETIRED volunteer physicians, nurses, dentists, pharmacists, etc., all anxious to continue to put their clinical skills to good use, especially now that they don’t have to worry about running a practice as a business. Many in their 70’s, retired for years, but still going strong.  

Bottom Line. So, is it really wrong for a doctor not to work full time practicing medicine until she dies, worried the whole time about finances and burning out? 

I am going with a big “No” on that one! How about you???

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *